Gas Tankless Water Heaters vs. Electric Models: Which is Right for You?

Home / Gas Tankless Water Heaters / Gas Tankless Water Heaters vs. Electric Models: Which is Right for You?
HVAC contractor in Livermore, California Best HVAC contractor in Livermore, California Top HVAC contractor Air conditioning contractor Livermore Heating contractor Livermore Residential HVAC contractor Commercial HVAC contractor

Gas Tankless Water Heaters vs. Electric Models: Which is Right for You?

Choosing between gas tankless water heaters with a pilot light and electric models can be a pivotal decision for homeowners. The efficiency, cost-effectiveness, and environmental impact of gas water heaters, gas tankless water heater, and electric heater systems vary significantly, making it essential to weigh the pros and cons carefully. In this comprehensive comparison, the key factors influencing your choice will be dissected with precision.


When considering which type of water heater best suits your needs, factors such as energy efficiency, installation costs, maintenance requirements, and overall performance must be taken into account. Understanding how a gas tankless water heater aligns with your specific household’s demands is crucial in making an informed decision that ensures long-term satisfaction.

Table of Contents

Understanding Demand-Type Water Heaters

Definition of Demand-Type Water Heaters

Demand-type water heaters, also known as tankless water heaters, are appliances that heat water only when it’s needed. Unlike traditional tank water heaters, which store and continuously heat a large amount of water, tankless models provide hot water on demand. When you turn on the hot water tap, cold water travels through a pipe into the unit where either a gas burner or an electric element heats it instantaneously.


Tankless models differ from traditional tank-based systems in their approach to heating and storing hot water. Traditional tanks keep a reservoir of heated water available at all times, while demand-type units don’t store any preheated water, thus eliminating standby energy losses associated with traditional tanks.

Benefits of Demand-Type Water Heaters

One significant benefit of demand-type water heaters is their energy efficiency. Since they don’t have to constantly maintain a supply of hot water, they use less energy overall compared to traditional tank-based systems. This can result in lower utility bills over time.


Another advantage is space savings. Tankless units are typically smaller than traditional tanks and can be mounted on walls or installed in compact spaces like closets or under sinks.


Moreover, demand-type models offer an uninterrupted supply of hot water since they heat it as required rather than relying on stored reserves that may deplete during periods of high usage.


In terms of longevity, tankless models generally last longer than traditional tanks because they aren’t susceptible to corrosion from long-term exposure to standing water.

Comparing Gas and Electric Tankless Water Heaters

Overview of Gas Tankless Water Heaters

Gas tankless water heaters are a type of water heater that heats water on demand using gas as the fuel source. They heat water quickly and efficiently, providing a constant supply of hot water whenever needed. These units use either natural gas or propane to heat the water, making them an excellent choice for homeowners who have access to natural gas or prefer its efficiency.


Gas tankless models tend to have higher flow rates compared to their electric counterparts, making them suitable for larger households with high hot water demands. They are known for their ability to deliver hot water at a consistent temperature without fluctuations even when multiple appliances are in use simultaneously.


One key consideration with gas tankless units is the cost of installation and potential venting requirements due to the combustion process involved. Homeowners need to ensure proper ventilation and comply with safety regulations when installing gas tankless water heaters due to the exhaust produced during operation.

Overview of Electric Tankless Water Heaters

Electric tankless water heaters operate by heating up cold water directly through an electrical element as it flows through the unit. These models do not require a storage tank like traditional water heaters, saving space and ensuring there’s always hot water available on demand without running out.


Electric tankless models are typically more compact than gas ones, allowing for flexible installation options such as under sinks or in small utility closets. They also eliminate standby energy loss associated with storage tanks since they only activate when hot water is needed.


While electric tankless units may have lower upfront costs compared to gas versions, they generally have lower flow rates which may not be sufficient for larger households or simultaneous usage across multiple fixtures. This can result in reduced performance during peak usage times if multiple applications require hot water simultaneously.

Key Differences Between Gas and Electric Tankless Water Heaters

Gas tankless water heaters and electric tankless water heaters are different because they use different kinds of energy. Gas ones use natural gas, which is a type of fuel that burns to make heat. Electric ones use electricity, which is the power that comes from the outlets in your home. 


The gas ones can handle more water flowing through them at once, which is good if you have a big family and lots of people using hot water at the same time. But, they might cost more to put in because they need special vents to let out the fumes from burning the gas. On the other hand, the electric ones are smaller and usually cheaper when you first buy them. But, they might not work as well if you need a lot of hot water all at once. That’s because they might not be able to heat up the water fast enough to keep up with everyone using it. 


So, you have to think about how much hot water your family uses and how your home is set up when you decide which kind of water heater is best for you. If you have a big family and lots of people using hot water at once, a gas one might be better for you even though it costs more to install. But if you don’t need as much hot water all at once, an electric one might be just right for your family and your home.

Efficiency of Electric vs. Gas Tankless Water Heaters

Energy Efficiency

Gas tankless water heaters are generally more energy-efficient than their electric counterparts. This is because they use natural gas or propane to heat the water, which results in a faster heating process compared to electric units. Gas models can produce a higher flow rate and deliver hot water more quickly, making them ideal for larger households with high hot water demands. On the other hand, electric tankless water heaters may struggle to keep up with simultaneous hot water usage in multiple appliances.


Gas tankless units have an edge due to their ability to provide a continuous supply of hot water without fluctuations in temperature. The electrical power required by electric models often leads to slower heating times and potential temperature inconsistencies when used simultaneously across different outlets.

Factors Impacting Efficiency

The efficiency of both types of tankless water heaters is influenced by various factors such as incoming water temperature, fuel type availability, and the cost of electricity versus natural gas or propane. For instance, areas with colder groundwater temperatures may require more energy input from either gas or electric units to achieve the desired hot water output.


Electricity prices also play a crucial role in determining the overall efficiency and cost-effectiveness of electric tankless models. Higher electricity rates can significantly impact the long-term operational costs associated with these units compared to using natural gas for heating purposes.


Factors like installation location and maintenance requirements also contribute to overall efficiency considerations when choosing between gas and electric tankless models. Proper ventilation for gas units is essential for safety and optimal performance, while regular maintenance helps sustain efficient operation over time for both types of systems.

Long-Term Cost Savings

While initial purchase costs might favor some electric models due to simpler installation 


requirements, long-term cost savings are often attributed more towards efficient gas-powered tankless systems that offer lower operating expenses over time. The reduced energy consumption of gas units, especially in regions where natural gas prices are relatively low compared to electricity rates, can result in significant savings on monthly utility bills.


Considering the longer lifespan typically associated with well-maintained gas-powered appliances compared to certain electrical components prone to wear out faster under heavy usage conditions contributes further towards long-term cost-effectiveness when opting for efficient gas tankless water heaters.

Heating Mechanisms of Electric and Gas Tankless Water Heaters

Electric Tankless Water Heater Heating Process

Electric tankless water heaters use electricity to heat water instantly when a hot water tap is turned on. Inside the unit, cold water flows through pipes where electric elements, typically made of copper and nickel, heat the water. As the water passes over these heated elements, it quickly reaches the desired temperature for use in showers, sinks, or appliances.


The heating process in electric tankless models involves an electrical resistance element that heats up when current passes through it. This causes rapid heating of the surrounding water, ensuring a constant supply of hot water whenever needed. The absence of a storage tank means that electric models do not experience standby heat loss like traditional storage tank heaters.


Electric tankless water heaters use a special thing called an electrical resistance element to heat the water. This means that when you turn on the hot water, the electrical resistance element quickly heats up the water as it flows through the heater. It’s like magic! Also, because electric tankless water heaters don’t have big storage tanks like traditional water heaters, they don’t have standby heat loss. That means they only use electricity to heat water when you need it, which can help save energy and money on your electricity bill. If you live in a place where electricity is more affordable or if you want to save on energy costs, an electric tankless water heater might be a good choice for you. Just remember that you might need to make sure your home’s electrical system can handle the extra power needed for an electric tankless water heater.


Gas Tankless Water Heater Heating Process on the other hand, gas tankless water heaters rely on natural gas or propane to rapidly heat water as it moves through a coiled pipe system within the unit. When a hot water tap is opened, sensors detect the flow and ignite the gas burner which then heats up the coils containing cold water, providing instant access to hot water.


The performance differences between gas and electric tankless models are mainly attributed to their respective heating mechanisms. While both types offer on-demand hot water, gas-powered units tend to have higher flow rates than their electric counterparts because they can achieve higher temperatures more quickly due to their powerful burners.


Performance Differences Based on Heating Mechanisms:


  • Gas units provide higher flow rates due to powerful burners
  • Electric units ensure consistent temperature without standby heat loss

Both types have distinct advantages based on their specific heating processes: while electric units eliminate energy waste from standby losses by directly warming incoming cold water, gas units deliver faster and more substantial amounts of heated water thanks to their potent burning mechanism.

Factors to Consider Before Choosing a Tankless Water Heater

Sizing Considerations

When choosing between gas tankless water heaters and electric models, it’s crucial to consider the sizing requirements. The size of the unit should be based on the hot water demand in your household. For instance, a larger family with higher hot water usage will require a more powerful unit compared to a smaller household. It’s essential to accurately assess your hot water needs before making a decision.


Properly sizing your tankless water heater ensures that you have an adequate supply of hot water when needed without overworking the unit. If you underestimate your needs, you may end up with insufficient hot water, while overestimating can lead to unnecessary energy consumption.

Hot Water Demand Assessment

To determine the right model for your home, it’s important to conduct an assessment of your daily hot water usage. This involves considering factors such as the number of bathrooms, appliances that use hot water (like dishwashers and washing machines), and peak usage times during mornings or evenings.


For example, if there are multiple bathrooms in use simultaneously during peak hours in your home, it would require a high-demand model capable of supplying sufficient hot water at those times without any drop in temperature or pressure.


Considering these aspects is crucial as it directly impacts the performance and efficiency of the chosen tankless water heater.

Environmental Impact and Location-Specific Factors

Another important consideration when deciding between gas and electric tankless models is their environmental impact and location-specific factors. Gas-powered units emit greenhouse gases during operation while electric models consume electricity that might be generated from fossil fuels.


If you live in an area with limited access to natural gas or where electricity costs are relatively low compared to other regions, opting for an electric model might be more cost-effective. On the other hand, if renewable energy sources like solar power are prevalent in your area or if natural gas is abundant and affordable, a gas-powered unit could be more environmentally friendly and economical in terms of operational costs.


Location-specific factors also include considerations such as altitude which can affect combustion air quality for gas units or electrical voltage stability for electric models.

Installation and Maintenance of Tankless Water Heaters

Installation Requirements

Installing a gas tankless water heater typically requires a gas line, which may not be present in all homes. These units need proper venting to expel the combustion gases safely. On the other hand, electric tankless water heaters require adequate electrical service to power them efficiently. They often need a dedicated circuit breaker due to their high power consumption.


For example, if a homeowner does not have an existing gas line or sufficient electrical service, they may need to incur additional costs for installation. This could influence their decision on whether to choose a gas or electric tankless water heater based on their home’s current setup.


Both types of tankless water heaters also necessitate regular maintenance for optimal performance and longevity.

Maintenance Needs and Best Practices

To ensure smooth operation and extend the service life of both gas and electric tankless water heaters, homeowners should adhere to specific maintenance practices. Flushing the gas tankless water heater unit regularly helps prevent mineral buildup that can decrease efficiency over time. This is particularly crucial in areas with hard water.


Furthermore, checking the pilot light is essential for gas tankless water heaters, as it ensures proper ignition of the burner when hot water is needed. In contrast, electric models might require periodic inspection of heating elements and wiring connections to identify any potential issues early on.

Propane vs. Natural Gas vs. Electric Tankless Water Heaters

Advantages of Propane Tankless Water Heaters

Propane tankless water heaters are highly efficient and can provide hot water on demand, making them ideal for smaller homes or vacation properties with limited hot water needs. They are also versatile, as they can be installed virtually anywhere, including off-grid locations where natural gas may not be available. Propane tankless water heaters tend to have lower upfront costs compared to electric models due to their simpler installation requirements.


Despite these advantages, it’s important to consider the considerations associated with propane tankless water heaters. One key consideration is the need for regular propane refills or deliveries, which adds an ongoing cost and maintenance requirement that may not be present with natural gas or electric models. Moreover, while propane is a clean-burning fuel, it produces carbon dioxide when burned, contributing to environmental concerns.

Considerations for Natural Gas Tankless Water Heaters

Natural gas tankless water heaters offer similar benefits as their propane counterparts in terms of efficiency and instant hot water delivery. The primary advantage of natural gas models lies in their typically lower operational costs compared to both electric and propane options due to the generally lower cost of natural gas as a fuel source.


On the other hand, there are some considerations specific to natural gas tankless water heaters that should be taken into account before making a decision. These units require access to a natural gas supply line which might limit installation options based on property location and infrastructure availability. While natural gas is considered a cleaner burning fuel than some alternatives like oil or coal, it still produces greenhouse gases during combustion.

Unique Benefits of Electric Tankless Water Heaters

Electric tankless water heaters boast several unique benefits that make them an attractive choice for many homeowners. They are often more compact than their gas-powered counterparts and do not require venting systems since they produce no emissions during operation—making them suitable for indoor installations even in small spaces.


In addition to these benefits, electric tankless water heaters are known for their ease of installation and low maintenance requirements compared to both propane and natural gas models. Furthermore, electric units eliminate the need for storing potentially hazardous fuels like propane or relying on access to a municipal supply line like with natural gas systems.


Gas tankless water heaters come in two main types: propane and natural gas. Propane tankless water heaters are known for their high efficiency and versatility. They can be used in various settings, such as homes, cabins, and even RVs. Plus, they usually have lower upfront costs compared to electric models.


On the other hand, natural gas tankless water heaters boast lower operational costs because natural gas is often cheaper than propane. Additionally, natural gas is considered a cleaner burning fuel, making it a more environmentally friendly option. It’s important to consider your specific needs and the availability of gas sources in your area when deciding between these two types of gas tankless water heaters.

Choosing the Right Tankless Water Heater for Your Home

Budget Considerations

When deciding between gas tankless water heaters and electric models, it’s crucial to consider budget constraints. For many homeowners, the initial purchase price is a significant factor. Electric tankless water heaters typically have a lower purchase price compared to their gas counterparts. This makes them an attractive choice for those on a tight budget or looking for a cost-effective option.


However, it’s essential to keep in mind that while electric models may be cheaper upfront, they can lead to higher energy bills over time. Gas tankless water heaters might have a higher initial purchase price, but they often result in lower monthly energy costs due to the generally lower cost of natural gas compared to electricity.


In some cases, homeowners may need to weigh the immediate financial strain against long-term savings when making their decision. It’s important not only to consider the upfront cost but also factor in potential long-term savings from reduced energy consumption.

Customization Options

Another crucial aspect when choosing between gas and electric tankless water heaters is customization options based on specific home setups. Homes vary greatly in terms of size, layout, and existing infrastructure. Electric models are usually more suitable for smaller homes or areas where natural gas isn’t readily available.


On the other hand, larger households with high hot water demand may benefit more from gas tankless water heaters due to their ability to provide continuous hot water flow at multiple points simultaneously without any lag time.


For example:


  • A small apartment with limited space might find an electric model more suitable due to its compact size and easy installation.
  • In contrast, a large family living in a spacious house might opt for a gas-powered unit capable of meeting heavy hot water demands without compromising performance.

Improving Energy Efficiency in Water Heating Systems

Insulation for Energy Conservation

Insulating water heaters and the hot water pipes can help retain heat, reducing the need for constant reheating. By minimizing heat loss, you can improve energy efficiency regardless of whether you choose a gas or electric model. For instance, wrapping an insulating blanket around your tankless water heater can prevent standby heat loss and lower your energy bills.


Insulated hot water pipes also ensure that the heated water maintains its temperature as it travels to your faucets or appliances. This means less wasted energy from reheating lukewarm water in the pipes each time you turn on the tap.

Optimizing Temperature Settings

Adjusting the temperature settings on both gas and electric tankless water heaters is crucial for maximizing energy efficiency while meeting your hot water needs. Lowering the temperature setting reduces standby heat losses and minimizes excessive heating, which helps conserve energy.


For example, lowering the preset temperature by just a few degrees can lead to significant savings on your utility bills without sacrificing comfort. Moreover, many modern tankless models offer precise controls that allow users to set their desired temperatures with accuracy.


Understanding the differences between gas and electric tankless water heaters is crucial for making an informed decision. Efficiency, heating mechanisms, fuel types, and installation considerations all play a role in determining the right choice for your home. By carefully weighing these factors, homeowners can select a water heater that aligns with their energy efficiency goals and household needs. Whether it’s the lower operating costs of electric models or the higher initial investment but long-term savings of gas units, choosing the right tankless water heater can lead to improved energy efficiency and cost savings in the long run.


For those considering a new water heater, conducting thorough research and consulting with professionals can provide valuable insights into the best options available. Understanding the nuances of gas and electric tankless water heaters empowers homeowners to make environmentally conscious and economically sound choices for their homes.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What are demand-type water heaters?

Demand-type water heaters, also known as tankless water heaters, provide hot water only as it is needed. They do not produce standby energy losses associated with storage water heaters, which can save you money.

2. Which is more efficient: gas or electric tankless water heaters?

Gas tankless water heaters tend to be more efficient than electric ones due to the higher heating capacity of natural gas or propane compared to electricity. However, the efficiency can vary based on usage patterns and climate.

3. What factors should I consider before choosing a tankless water heater?

Factors such as your home’s size, hot-water needs, available fuel type (natural gas, propane, or electricity), installation costs, and maintenance requirements should all be taken into account when selecting a tankless water heater.

4. How do propane vs. natural gas vs. electric tankless water heaters differ?

Propane and natural gas tankless models operate similarly but use different types of fuel. Electric units rely on electrical resistance heating elements for heating. Each fuel type has its own set of advantages and considerations in terms of cost and availability.

5. How can I improve energy efficiency in my electric or gas water heating system?

To improve energy efficiency in your system:


  • Insulate hot-water pipes
  • Use low-flow fixtures
  • Consider a solar thermal system
  • Install an ENERGY STAR-certified unit Regular maintenance and setting the right temperature will also help optimize energy use.

Ensure Efficient and Safe Heating: Choose Superior Mechanical for Your Gas Tankless Water Heater Needs

Is your heating system efficient and safe for a comfortable and sustainable environment? Don’t let outdated or inefficient heaters compromise the warmth and safety of your business premises. Trust Superior Mechanical Services, Inc., your reliable partner in providing and maintaining gas tankless water heaters. Since 1948, we have been a beacon of trust and expertise in the San Francisco Bay Area, serving communities like Livermore, Dublin, and Pleasanton with unwavering dedication. Our certified technicians specialize in the installation, maintenance, and repair of gas tankless water heaters, ensuring your space benefits from consistent, energy-efficient heating.


But our commitment extends beyond mere installations. We are devoted to educating our clients. After expertly setting up your gas tankless water heater, we provide essential guidance and tips to optimize its performance and longevity. Choosing Superior Mechanical Services means more than just upgrading your heating system; it’s about embracing a more efficient, eco-friendly, and cost-effective heating solution. Contact us today for exceptional services in gas tankless water heater solutions, and transform your space into a model of efficiency and comfort!


Previous Article      Home       Next Article

Air conditioning contractor, Heating contractor

For any kind of HVAC installation, repair, and maintenance requirement contact our experts by email at or call (925) 456-3200

Skip to content